Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Dreams and Fiction: Chaucer, Goodwin, and Nolan

Philip Goodwin wrote a text called The mystery of dreames, historically discoursed; or A treatise; wherein is clearly discovered, the secret yet certain good or evil, the inconsidered and yet assured truth or falsity, virtue or vanity, misery or mercy, of mens differing dreames. Their distinguishing characters: the divers cases, causes, concomitants, consequences, concerning mens inmost thoughts while asleep. With severall considerable questions, objections, and answers contained therein: and other profitable truths appertaining thereunto. Are from pertinent texts plainly and fully unfolded (heretofore referred to as The Mystery of Dreames) in which he interprets the meaning of dreams and discusses how deceptive they can be. 



Goodwin describes dreams in many different ways. He goes so far as to compare his interpretation of them to the accomplishments of Aristotle, Cicero, Galen, and Hypocrates. He claims that because dreams are of such a dark nature, they need a wise and noble interpreter such as himself. If one is not noble, not pure enough, he or she may be more likely to fall prey to the dangers of one's deceitful dreams. Of particular interest are the passages in which Goodwin compares dreaming to fiction. He writes:

"In a Dreame there is somewhat ap|peares to the thoughts. A dreaming Man (sayes Austin) he thinks he sees the Sun, though the Sun he sees not. As there may appeare some things to our eyes, as Armies in the air, fighting-men, and flying-Horses which are no realities, only apparitions. So to a man in a Dream, such things & persons appear but they are no realities, only fictions in his fancy. Philo observes, that some awake are like to men asleep, while they think they perceive such things, do but deceive themselves, taking the signs of things, for the natures of things, meer Shadows for Substance. In a Dream are thoughts of things, not the things thought" (11-12).



Goodwin's text acts as a type of guide for deciphering the meaning of different dreams, and how they can lie to the person having them. He essentially says that dreams are make-believe, they're not real, and therefore they're a lie. Because a man thinks he sees the sun in a dream, but actually does not see the sun, there is no reality to dreaming. Of course, in the last section of the text, Goodwin makes the connection between dreaming and Satan. He writes, "But Satan is subtill and may soon deceive men with Dreams meerly pretended from God" (315). Under the guise of God, according to Goodwin, Satan is able to trick simple people into doing what he wants.

The observations in The Mystery of Dreames shed much positive light on religious dreams as well, seeing as Goodwin was a preacher, despite the fact that the devil often appears in dreams to tempt the dreamer toward sin. He eventually goes on to classify people who dream into "Deceivers" and those who are "Deceived" (48). Divine dreams are special cases, such as with the Patriarch Joseph - whom he refers to as the "Captain-Dreamer" (4) - and the Prophet Daniel. Both men were unusually skilled at interpreting their divine dream, and because they received visions from God, there was nothing dark or misleading about them.

He seems to be walking a fine line between whether dreams are evil and dishonest at the hands of Satan or if they are holy and revealing at the hands of God. Goodwin seems to believe that it was his duty to write this guide as he alone can tell the difference between the bad dreams and the good dreams, between fiction and non-fiction.

The idea of dreaming as fiction correlates strongly to Geoffrey Chaucer's The House of Fame.



The House of Fame takes the form of a dream vision in which, upon falling asleep, the poet finds himself in a glass temple adorned with images of famous people and their various deeds. Similar to The Mystery of Dreames, Chaucer's text starts out by speculating on the nature and causes of dreams. However, Goodwin spends the majority of his text making such speculations while Chaucer dives straight into his story from there.

Chaucer also takes a very meta approach to his writing. Although the story is clearly fiction, he is inserting himself into the narrative, telling the audience that he is going to explain to them a dream he had in extreme detail. He asks that nobody misinterprets the meaning of his dream, which is similar to Goodwin in that both men believe their interpretation, and theirs alone, is the right one. Then, Chaucer comes across an eagle, which acts as a guide throughout the remainder of his dream, with which he discusses the credibility of what is known about recorded fame.

Once again, we are in a dream with a writer questioning the honesty of what is happening in the dream. Chaucer is left wondering what his role is in reporting the lives of the famous and to what extent of honesty. Towards the end, he finds himself in a place with a large crowd and everyone is spreading rumors. Of rumors, he writes:

"And whan that was ful yspronge,
 And woxen more on every tonge
 Than ever hit was, [hit] wente anoon
 Up to a wyndowe out to goon;
 Or, but hit myghte out there pace,
 Hyt gan out crepe at som crevace,
 And flygh forth faste for the nones.
 And somtyme saugh I thoo at ones
 A lesyng and a sad soth sawe,
 That gonne of aventure drawe
 Out at a wyndowe for to pace;
 And, when they metten in that place,
 They were achekked bothe two,
 And neyther of hem moste out goo
 For other, so they gonne crowde,
 Til ech of hem gan crien lowde,
 'Lat me go first!' 'Nay, but let me!'" (2081-2097).

In Middle English "lesyng" means "lying" and "soth" means "truth." Therefore, Chaucer is saying that, sometimes, he would see a false rumor and an honest one arriving together, and they would fight to see which one of them could fly out the window first. It's interesting that at first, the two exist in harmony, and then, when it's time for them to leave, they begin to argue. To me, it feels like Chaucer is making a point about the coexistence of dreams and rumor, of the truth and the lie. The way that he tells his audience about his dream could be seen as gossiping, another form of rumor. That's not to mention his running commentary about the honesty of recorded fame. Who's to say that what Chaucer is telling us is true, meaning that he actually woke up from a dream and remembered all the extraordinarily vivid details, or he is just telling a story?

To Goodwin, there might not be a difference, if dreams are fiction. Whether Chaucer thought this up in his head while he was awake or actually dreamed up The House of Fame in his sleep, Goodwin would categorize both of those as fictitious, false, even dishonest. Chaucer's text seems to be teaching that "fame is a fickle friend," but his ideas about rumors and fame are tied in with the honesty of it all, and it's happening in a dream, whereas what Goodwin is essentially trying to do in his text is to explain which dreams are good and honest and which are bad and untruthful. They approach the idea of dreaming and lying in very different ways, but they come to similar conclusions. Goodwin believes that he is a master dream interpreter, and Chaucer in the beginning asked his audience to interpret no other meaning from his dream than the one he provides.

The best modern representation of dreaming and fiction is Christopher Nolan's 2010 film Inception



In its earliest stages, Inception started out as an 80-page treatment written by Nolan about "dream stealers," and was originally going to be a horror film inspired by lucid dreaming. After spending six months revising the script, it finally developed into the ever-popular heist film. He had decided that it wouldn't work in the horror genre because the story relies so heavily on the idea of the interior state, the idea of dream and memory, and he wanted to raise the emotional stakes.

Nolan was influenced heavily by the movies coming out at that time that were based in the principles that the world around you might not be real, such as The Matrix, Dark City, The Thirteenth Floor, and Memento. Pretty early on in production, he realized that they would need a bigger budget for the film. Nolan said:

 "As soon as you're talking about dreams, the potential of the human mind is infinite. And so, the scale of the film has to to feel infinite. It has to feel like you could go anywhere by the end of the film. And it has to work on a massive scale" (Itzkoff).

This idea of the human mind's potential as infinite in a dream is something that both The House of Fame and Inception have in common. Chaucer created what was essentially an intricate alternate reality in a single dream, and was able to remember three books worth of information from it. Similarly, in Inception, the concept of dreaming has no limitations. That is something that Goodwin does not really touch on in The Mystery of Dreames. He focuses much more heavily on the meaning of dreams rather than their potential. 

The plot behind Inception is based entirely around dreaming. The main character is an "Extractor" whose job it is to infiltrate the subconscious of their targets and extract valuable information. Then, he and a team become involved in a shared dream, where they continue going deeper into different levels of each other's subconscious and they have to carry around totems with them to remind them that they are in a dream, not reality, and they have to leave behind these "kicks" at each level that allows them to go back to the surface. It's a film in which it is very difficult to separate what is real and what is happening in a dream, made even more confusing by the ending in which the protagonist tests his totem to see if his whole life is a dream or not, but the audience never finds out the truth.

In both Goodwin and Chaucer's texts, there was a distinct line between dream and reality. Goodwin knew that he was interpreting dreams and that they were false, fictitious. Chaucer was recounting a tale of his dream, inviting the reader to believe that the entire tale happened inside his head while he was asleep. Inception  is different in the way that it blurs dreaming with reality, fiction with fact. It's a technique popular in the modern film scene, whereas it might not have gone over so well in Renaissance literature. The big budget dream sequences work well in cinema where there is a visual to make sense of it all, but I imagine that a novelization of the movie Inception would be almost impossible to follow.

No comments:

Post a Comment