Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Masks and False Appearances: Bodenham, Jonson, and Kelley


Be-lvedere, or, The Garden of the muses (or simply Belvedere) is a commonplace book made up of 89 play extracts from six Shakespeare plays (Richard II, Richard III, Henry VI Part 2, Romeo and Juliet, Love's Labor's Lost, and Henry IV Part 1) and 125 extracts from two Shakespeare poems (Lucrece and Venus and Adonis). John Bodenham collected the extracts, which were then arranged by the editor, Anthony Munday.


Shakespeare's lines, mingled with those of other writers as well, fall under thematic headings such as "Of Conscience" and "Of Truth" to form entirely new musings. A book crafted from the minds of many different writers can be summed up most accurately in a line from the heading, "Of Death" which was originally from Shakespeare's Richard II.

"There's nothing we can call our own but death" (231).

Because this commonplace book is an amalgam of writings from so many different sources, it doesn't seem quite fair to attribute the text entirely to Shakespeare or entirely to Bodenham. Each section is a musing in its own right, a sort of literary Frankenstein, composed of different pieces, wearing a shiny new mask in place of the old one. It's almost as if each section is pretending to be something that it is not, or at least, acting as something new that it did not used to be.

This is interesting especially upon paying close attention to the "Of Truth" section that falls toward the beginning of Belvedere. This is not all from one writer, play, or poem, but it does a really great job of combining the different parts into one cohesive being.

"Where then is truth, if there be no selfe trust?
Truth is the onely shield of best defence.
When truely in our selues our faults we see,
We deeme them known to all, as well as wee.
An honest tale speeds best being truly told.
Truth may be shent, but neuer shall be sham'd.
Truth to all goodnesse is the perfect guide.
All doubts resoluing, is by finding truth.
How shall he thinke to find a straunger iust,
That in himselfe dare put no confidence?
False dreames do euermore the truth deny.
Time shewes the truth, and wit that's bought is best.
Truth soundeth sweetly in a sillie tongue.
Who cherish wrongs, are bent against the truth.
Truth needeth not the aid of Rhetoricke.
Happie the people, blessed is the land,
Where truth and vertue get the vpper hand.
Nothing so hard, but is by truth explain'd.
All hidden secrets, truth can best disclose.
Truth to all goodnes, is the perfect guide.
Truth hath two friends; Wisdome, and Constancie.
Truth standeth not vpon the tongues of men:
Nor Honour, on authorities bigge frownes" (14).


According to this, truth is the be-all and end-all to everything. Look no further than the truth for an answer to any problem. Truth is the best defense, the perfect guide, the ideal companion to wisdom. However, Bodenham's compilation could almost appear untruthful in the way that it is hiding under the guise of these new headings, all these pieces standing together as one, when in their pure, original form, they have come from different texts. 

Similarly, the characters in Ben Jonson's The Alchemist are wearing disguises, pretending to be something they're not. 


In The Alchemist, everything is not what it seems (just as the musings in Belvedere are not precisely what they appear to be), or rather, everyone is not who they seem. The main characters are named Subtle and Face, and they very rarely appear on stage as themselves because they are always dressed up in disguise as part of a ruse to get people to pay them money for a fake Philosopher's Stone.

Subtle pretends to be not only the Alchemist, but also the Doctor. Face is also Jeremy the butler, Ulen Spiegel/Lungs, and Captain Face. Interestingly, although Subtle and Face are never whom they appear to be, their names would imply that they are exactly who they claim to be. Subtle is the one with the clever plans, putting on "subtle" ruses in order to make money, and Face is the face of all the action. He goes out in different disguises and lures in potential clients. Everyone else in in the play has similar names that would suggest outwardly who they are: Dol Common (meaning "everyone's") is a prostitute, Dapper is a legal clerk and a social climber, Drugger is a young tobacconist, and Surly is a bitter sidekick.

These titles actually relate back to the headings used in Belvedere because they explain exactly what follows. Bodenham's section "Of Truth" is about truth, and "Of Death" is about death. They are very obvious headings that leave nothing to the imagination, just as the names of Subtle and Face and Drugger and Surly indicate exactly the types of people that they are.

The Alchemist both contradicts and agrees with Belvedere's proclamation that the solution to any and all issues is to tell the truth. Obviously, Jonson's characters do everything except tell the truth, but for most of them, they receive the consequences they deserve at the end of the play, thus enforcing the idea that the best way is the honest way. When the authorities arrive at the end of the play to put an end to the scam, Subtle and Dol escape, penniless, out the back door. Face is left alone at stage, but he is left with the reward at least, so his ending is not completely unfortunate, which supports the idea that it is possible to lie and steal and cheat and still turn out okay.

Someone else who lied and ended up on top was the character of Emily Thorne/Amanda Clarke from ABC's 2011 television series Revenge. 


Mike Kelley, creator of the series, based Revenge off of the Alexandre Dumas novel The Count of Monte Cristo in terms of its plot. The protagonist, Amanda Clarke, moves to the Hamptons and rents a beach house that she and her father used to own when she was a child. She has changed her name to Emily Thorne and come back to avenge the death of her father, who was framed for a crime committed by some of the rich people of the Hamptons. Her father was killed in prison, and that was when Amanda Clarke became Emily Thorne and started following through with the ultimate plan to get revenge on each and every person who wronged her father.

The series lasted four seasons before it came to its conclusion in which Emily Thorne settles down with her childhood sweetheart, finally takes down the last of her father's enemies, and lives happily ever after. She proved that lying could be okay if it was for a good reason. She wasn't lying to benefit herself because she was in pursuit of justice for her father. I think that the truth in modern pop culture is less black and white than it was portrayed in Renaissance literature.

In Bodenham's Belvedere, the truth was always the right answer because of its purity, its goodness, its wisdom. In Jonson's The Alchemist, most of the characters were liars, in pursuit of personal wealth, and two of them ended up broke and on the run from the cops, but one of them received the reward, even though he was left alone in the end. Then, in ABC's Revenge, Emily Thorne is lying to absolutely everyone she meets, but she's doing it for a good reason, and therefore, she gets a happy ending.

The conclusion that can be made here is that the truth is relative. While honesty is typically the best policy, sometimes liars get away with lying, and sometimes lies can be told for good reasons. Throughout revenge, Emily's time in the Hamptons was anything but sunshine and rainbows. She had to lie to the people that she loved in order to protect them, and she had to deal with a lot of dangerous people in order to get justice for her father. She had to play the game that they were all playing, but she had to play it better than anyone else. Emily Thorne is the prime example of a strong, independent woman who became a vigilante in the most bad-ass of ways. Her con was far superior to that of Face and Subtle, and she proved the musings in "Of Truth" wrong by lying and still getting her fairy tale ending.

No comments:

Post a Comment