Monday, May 9, 2016

Power and Lying: Shakespeare, Fletcher, and Branagh


The Bloody Brother was originally titled Rollo Duke of Normandy and is said to have been a collaboration between John Fletcher, Philip Massinger, Ben Jonson, and George Chapman. It is loosely based on the historical Viking duke of Normandy, Rollo. 

Amidst all of Rollo's bloodthirsty deeds lies prominent themes of deception and falsehood. In particular, Sophia, who is the mother to Rollo and his brother Otto, gives her sons some sage advice. 

"Know yet, my sons, when of necessity
You must deceive, or be deceiv'd; 'tis better
To suffer treason, than to act the traytor;
And in a war like this, in which the glory
Is his that's overcome: consider then
What 'tis for which you strive: is it the dukedome?
Or the command of these so ready subjects?
Desire of wealth? or whatsoever else
Fires your ambition? This still desp'rate madnesse,
To kill the people which you would be lords of;
With fire, and sword, to lay that countrey waste
Whose rule you seeke for: to consume the treasures,
Which are the sinewes of your government,
In cherishing the factions that destroy it:
Far, far be this from you: make it not questiond
Whether you have intrest in that dukedome,
Whose ruine both contend for" (Act 1, scene 1).


Their mother is telling them that it is better to lie than to be lied to, and that is what must be done in order not only to survive, but to thrive, and to achieve the power that they so desperately seek. With a mother who encouraged such methods, it is no wonder that Rollo turned out the way he did, killing everyone in his path in order to get what he wanted. That was his own form of deception. 

Similarly, in Shakespeare's King Lear, also in Act 1, a parent is asking his children to lie in order to obtain power. Lear gathers his three daughters and tells them that whoever proclaims to love him the most will receive the biggest chunk of land. 

"Meantime we shall express our darker purpose.
Give me the map there. Know that we have divided
In three our kingdom: and 'tis our fast intent
To shake all cares and business from our age;
Conferring them on younger strengths, while we
Unburthen'd crawl toward death. Our son of Cornwall,
And you, our no less loving son of Albany,
We have this hour a constant will to publish
Our daughters' several dowers, that future strife
May be prevented now. The princes, France and Burgundy,
Great rivals in our youngest daughter's love,
Long in our court have made their amorous sojourn,
And here are to be answer'd. Tell me, my daughters,--
Since now we will divest us both of rule,
Interest of territory, cares of state,--
Which of you shall we say doth love us most?
That we our largest bounty may extend
Where nature doth with merit challenge. Goneril,
Our eldest-born, speak first" (1.1.37-55).





Lear goes about his request in a different way than Sophia. He's not outright asking his daughters to lie. He is playing off of the belief that they all love him exponentially, and in his mind, the fairest way to divide up the kingdom between them is to force them to admit just how much they love him. Lear is much more selfish in his request than Sophia. He spends the rest of the play complaining about how two of his daughters, Goneril and Regan, are being mean to him. In The Bloody Brother, however, after the land is divided equally between Rollo and Otto by their father, Sophia spends her time trying to repair the riff between her two sons. In fact, she was never in favor of splitting the kingdom in half in the first place, claiming that each half would be that much weaker for it. She was always looking out for the best interests of her sons.

The ending for both Lear and Sophia is equally tragic, although in slightly different ways. After Cordelia, the only daughter that actually loved her father, is hanged, Lear has one final lucid moment in which he believes he sees her come back to life, before he dies himself. On the other hand, Sophia, after believing her two sons have reconciled, attends a banquet with her son Otto when Rollo storms in to kill him, and Otto uses his mother as a human shield, thus killing himself and Sophia in the process. Both parents die, more or less at the hands of their children - Sophia literally and physically by her sons; Lear, driven mad by his horrible daughters.

The most accurate modern representation of this phenomena occurs in Kenneth Branagh's 2011 American superhero film Thor. Brothers Thor and Loki are the sons of Odin, King of Asgard, and they have always upheld somewhat of a sibling rivalry. The rivalry is brought to its apex when Odin chooses Thor to succeed him instead of Loki. Unlike in King Lear or in The Bloody Brother, there is no division of the kingdom between the siblings, and because of this, Loki feels he has been done an unforgivable injustice. He was powerhungry, like Goneril and Regan, like Rollo and Otto, and he would have done anything to take the throne from his brother.



When Thor is banished to Earth by his father, Odin goes into what is essentially hibernation, Loki discovers that he is actually Odin's adoptive son, and during this time, he seizes the throne and offers his real father the chance to kill Odin. When Thor finally returns to Asgard, Loki betrays his real father and kills him, using the opportunity to pretend that he had saved Odin by thwarting his attempted assassination. Like Goneril and Regan lying to Lear in order to gain power, Loki is also willing to lie to Odin in order to achieve some recognition and power.

As in The Bloody Brother, Thor and Loki engage in a battle which may have ended in both of their deaths if not for the intervention of a parent. Although when Rollo and Otto fought, Otto used his mother's body as a shield and he still died, and what saved Thor and Loki from themselves was Odin waking up from his hibernation and breaking up the fight himself. Thor destroys the bridge that provided passage between Asgard and Earth, thus sacrificing his only way to get back to the girl he loved, and both brothers would have fallen into the abyss where the bridge used to be if Odin had not showed up to save them. Thor gratefully excepts his father's help, but when Odin rejects Loki's pleas for approval, Loki allows himself to fall into the void. Thor makes amends with his father and admits that he is not ready to be king.

That was something that none of the children did in the renaissance plays: admit that they were not ready to take the place of their parents. Cordelia refused to lie to her father to gain the kingdom, but when she was banished like Thor, she moved away to France and proved herself to be a worthy ruler there instead. Neither Regan, Goneril, Rollo, nor Otto seemed mature or responsible enough to take over a kingdom, but they all jumped at the chance to do so, no matter what the cost. Loki was the same way. Their problem was that they all wanted power too much. Thor was the only one to admit that he was not yet ready for that responsibility.

Although Odin did not meet the same fate as Sophia or King Lear, Loki's biological father did die at the hands of his own son. That is another significant difference between Renaissance plays and modern films. In Thor, the bad guys all got what was coming to them, for the most part. Loki lost, and his equally-as-evil father died for his treasonous assassination attempt. Odin saved the day and Thor came out on top, smelling fresh as a daisy. None of the good guys died or suffered a huge loss. The only downside Thor had to face was that he couldn't return to Earth to visit the girl he loved. In King Lear, on the contrary, almost everyone, good and bad, died at the end of the play. King Lear and Cordelia have especially tragic deaths, and Cordelia was arguably the most pure character of all. 

In The Bloody Brother, both of the brothers end up dead even after attempting to use women as their human shields (Otto - his mother, Sophia; Rollo - his betrothed, Edith). However, the innocent women that they utilize like puppets end up dead as well. The Renaissance plays had a knack for semi-justice whereas the audiences of modern cinema are left too unsatisfied if good does not end up triumphing over evil in the end.

No comments:

Post a Comment